MAIL ON SUNDAY ADOPTS ‘CHINESE WHISPERS’ METHOD OF REVIEWING INTEGRATION REPORT, ENDS UP WRITING MORE RUBBISH ABOUT MUSLIMS

notting_hill_carnival_crowd_-_august_2006

(Photo by DAVID ILIFF. License CC-BY-SA 3.0)

Just days after The Sun filed a woefully misleading article about a survey on British Muslims, the Mail on Sunday has offered up its own half-baked analysis on another government report which has made The Sun‘s effort seem like an academic masterpiece in comparison.

The paper achieved this by using an innovative new reviewing method – its journalists didn’t bother reading a single word of the report in question themselves. They simply reported what they’d heard others saying about it instead.

Writing about ‘A review into opportunity and integration’ by Dame Louise Casey, the MoS claims that the ‘shock report’ reveals that ‘Isolated British Muslims are so cut off from the rest of society that they see the UK as 75 per cent Islamic’.

So keen was the paper to draw its own conclusions from the contents of the report that it couldn’t wait for its own journalists to read a copy themselves, meaning the article was written ‘according to sources who have seen the report’.

Trouble is, the sources obviously didn’t do a very good job as nowhere in the 199-page report does it say that British Muslims think that the UK is 75 per cent Islamic.

What it does say, on page 49 of the report, is that pupils of one non-faith secondary school with a high Asian population believed that Asians made up between 50-90% of the British population. This was a survey that researchers were ‘told about’ on their visit.

integration-report

So apart from writing ‘isolated British Muslims’ instead of ‘pupils in a non-faith secondary school’, and ‘Islamic’ instead of ‘Asian’, and ‘75%’ instead of ’50-90%’, and ‘UK’ instead of ‘Britain’, the headline in the Mail on Sunday is absolutely spot on.

Dame Casey’s vast review into integration is drawn from interviews with over 800 people across Britain and includes chapters on segregation, interaction, public attitudes and the media, social and economic exclusion, inequality and harm, religion, hate and extremism. Full report available here.

Tabloid Corrections Facebook page: here.

Advertisements

One thought on “MAIL ON SUNDAY ADOPTS ‘CHINESE WHISPERS’ METHOD OF REVIEWING INTEGRATION REPORT, ENDS UP WRITING MORE RUBBISH ABOUT MUSLIMS

  1. […] Just days after The Sun filed a woefully misleading article about a survey on British Muslims, the Mail on Sunday has offered up its own half-baked analysis on another government report which has made The Sun‘s effort seem like an academic masterpiece in comparison. The paper achieved this by using an innovative new reviewing method […] Tabloid Corrections […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s